Skip to content

Pause, think and forget about the Chilean miners

October 12, 2010

You may be watching (or watched) the release of the trapped Chilean miners on TV. You may have followed it in news stories on Twitter. Or possibly even appreciated the graphics which detailed how their retrieval from deep underground has been made possible. Like me, you may possibly have sense an unerring and seemingly inexplicable sense of impending euphoria at the release of these men.

It’s human nature. We’re bound to get swept along by it, even though everyone the world (except a tiny minority of friends and relatives) don’t know them. They are a group of men with dirty faces and filthy vests who haven’t seen daylight for two months. They are the Chilean miners. That’s how we know them.

What we marvel in is their survival. Not for their sakes but for our own. It buoys our spirits. It gives us hope. It underpins our occasional wavering sense of determination. In those dark moments when we’re discouraged we latch on to breathtaking examples of human endeavour. It those moments which push us back on the path.

Somewhere in the back of our minds we justify our fascination with the plight of a group of men we don’t know and are never going to meet in person with the belief that something of ourselves is in that mine. Just as they are brought to the surface and released from their suffering so we will be too.

But, we should pause and reflect as they do see daylight (albeit through dark glasses so their retinas don’t get burnt) that their lives have changed irrevocably.

They will, from tomorrow onwards, be hounded both literally and metaphorically. People – people with dramatisations in their heads and audiences to satisfy – will want to make contact with them. They’ll chase. They’ll offer. They’ll persuade. They’ll lean. They’ll do whatever they can to get a story from one of them. They’ll think there’s an audience who will want to know every last detail of what that experience was like for them. And they’ll think that because they know that every one of us does have a little part of our brains reserved for such fascination that it’s OK to stop at nothing to seal the deal.

Which is why I say we should forget about the Chilean miners. Their deeply traumatic experiences – including the anecdotes of positivity in the face of adversity – are not our property. We do not have a right to know how they felt to be down there. We shouldn’t think that we do. If we have respect, if we are sensitive, if we are decent human beings then we should leave them be.

They have enough to deal with. So too their families. Because far from being released from their confinement they are .. unless we keep our own appetites in check at any rate .. about to suffer a different kind of trauma. If they’re unwillingly thrust into the media spotlight they will be trapped for the rest of their lives.

The picture used in this blog post is called ‘Trapped’ and was published by Flickr user Denis Messie. It’s used here in accordance with the Creative Commons Licence.

Advertisements

From → News & Sport

2 Comments
  1. cyberguycalif permalink

    “””””……… if we are decent human beings then we should leave them be.”””””

    That will not happen and if history tells us anything, somewhere in Hollywood a movie of all this must be wrapping up just waiting for the final end so they can end their movie. I bet TV stations have already secured rights with the families and book deals have already been made.

    Humans seem to want to know everything that is going on with everyone else. If people would mind their on business, this world might not be so mess up.

  2. An excellent post. To be honest I hadn’t given the miners *that* much thought as no sooner had I heard the news that they were trapped, there was also the news that they would be able to get out, albeit after a long time. But I caught some footage of it this morning on tv (never watch tv in the morning) and was surprised by how moved I was by the scenes. So yes I agree, the best thing for them would be to go back into blissful anonymity. But I fear Cyberguycalif has it right.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: